From 9e737b625298325b4c73cba9d5df8ad06d0d3a49 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 12:00:23 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] v4 init.4th pins the words that create or end nodes Captain Bob ruled: "Also pin the kernel words". After the policy loads, init.4th pins 11 words: BIRTH, BIRTH-AS, UNIT, KILL, UNIT-KILL, PAUSE, RESUME, NODE-BORN, NODE-KILL, NODE-SLEEP and NODE-WAKE. Their fields cannot be changed, so no policy can deny them. v4 has no CAPSULE-BIRTH. The wiring words, NODE-WIRE and NODE-UNWIRE, are not pinned; they neither create nor end a node. Test first in test_mesh_boot: each of the 11 is pinned. The before-run had all 11 unpinned. After: 114 checks pass, POST 990/990. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017RzZgrf7V7Zk2iczBXDRbm --- capsules/v4/init.4th | 7 ++ .../test_mesh_boot-after.log | 83 ++++++++++++++++ .../test_mesh_boot-before.log | 96 +++++++++++++++++++ v4/tests/test_mesh_boot.c | 12 +++ 4 files changed, 198 insertions(+) create mode 100644 logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-after.log create mode 100644 logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-before.log diff --git a/capsules/v4/init.4th b/capsules/v4/init.4th index 175b0e59..a88e5b3c 100644 --- a/capsules/v4/init.4th +++ b/capsules/v4/init.4th @@ -4,6 +4,13 @@ Block 3980 ( init.4th's. docs/v4.0.0/plans/2026-11-18-v4-init.md. ) ( Step 2, security on: the ACL policy, ACL.4th. ) S" v4:ACL.4th" CAPSULE-INCLUDE +( The words that create or end nodes, pinned: their fields ) +( cannot be changed, so no policy can deny them. ) +' BIRTH ACL-PIN ' BIRTH-AS ACL-PIN ' UNIT ACL-PIN +' KILL ACL-PIN ' UNIT-KILL ACL-PIN +' PAUSE ACL-PIN ' RESUME ACL-PIN +' NODE-BORN ACL-PIN ' NODE-KILL ACL-PIN +' NODE-SLEEP ACL-PIN ' NODE-WAKE ACL-PIN ( Step 1, the search order: STARSHIPOS, then FORTH. Last, ) ( since ACL.4th ends in FORTH DEFINITIONS. ) STARSHIPOS diff --git a/logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-after.log b/logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-after.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..2662b603 --- /dev/null +++ b/logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-after.log @@ -0,0 +1,83 @@ +mkcapsule: scanning /home/user/LithosAnanke/capsules + [p] zuse.4th (1684 bytes, hash=0x490ded9be257a90b) + [p] font.4th (17688 bytes, hash=0x3f305911500c78f6) + [p] MANIFEST_AUTO.md (11687 bytes, hash=0xe022545a0755960f) + [p] multiuser-doe.4th (3942 bytes, hash=0x22140588ee7c39e6) + [p] hestia:init.4th (891 bytes, hash=0x64e111990fbc45ff) + [p] contrib:README.md (1855 bytes, hash=0x4212e52b927793e7) + [p] ACL.4th (4318 bytes, hash=0xf8890c05c0d8f921) + [p] workload-3.4th (2189 bytes, hash=0x62b7a71576ad1041) + [p] init-l8-diverse.4th (430 bytes, hash=0xaa293201a6c91838) + [p] user-font-demo.4th (1674 bytes, hash=0xce1fd7d1b581a56d) + [p] workload-9.4th (1321 bytes, hash=0x3f2bec73142aa424) + [p] lib.4th (619 bytes, hash=0x4b216635c359ef73) + [p] workload-calib1.4th (304 bytes, hash=0x3b9f2d17b554fabc) + [m] init.4th (669 bytes, hash=0xd09db9461b336431) + [p] workload-1-lite.4th (540 bytes, hash=0x44a7a7e3176dcc8d) + [p] init-l8-stable.4th (278 bytes, hash=0xdc3830f189063a9a) + [p] v4:physics.4th (2953 bytes, hash=0x5b0195fc30828bde) + [p] v4:forth79.4th (1216 bytes, hash=0x4609d6ef54166ef8) + [p] v4:ACL.4th (2103 bytes, hash=0xdba5690fb0ee12a4) + [p] v4:init.4th (756 bytes, hash=0x13fe8932fa4d2934) + [p] v4:sys:log.f18 (4535 bytes, hash=0x544cd004233dff62) + [p] v4:sys:qmath.f18 (8607 bytes, hash=0xa93783c2c8f9b7db) + [p] v4:sys:map-32.f18 (3162 bytes, hash=0x5bdf8cbbebdd3c8f) + [p] v4:sys:blocks.f18 (6112 bytes, hash=0x09d361dbe6174236) + [p] v4:sys:input.f18 (10692 bytes, hash=0x0f13c3f9d5fd07fc) + [p] v4:sys:dict.f18 (13816 bytes, hash=0xe3453808afd5a0af) + [p] v4:sys:forth.f18 (12617 bytes, hash=0xc4c0ad315c95eda4) + [p] v4:sys:quit.f18 (32141 bytes, hash=0x7fa7a7668b6bf1ed) + [p] v4:sys:map-64.f18 (3201 bytes, hash=0x06cb44832df2b8fd) + [p] v4:sys:codegen.f18 (4999 bytes, hash=0x36d2ae84d2911b90) + [p] v4:sys:acl.f18 (4100 bytes, hash=0x76e7e746befa2733) + [p] v4:sys:core.f18 (24370 bytes, hash=0x0f415502fccc3fba) + [p] v4:sys:system.f18 (10189 bytes, hash=0xfe257eb084c43a5d) + [p] v4:sys:numout.f18 (6641 bytes, hash=0xca0fb0f9c1589e20) + [p] v4:sys:words.f18 (9642 bytes, hash=0x2f4e5f7f3e7f736f) + [p] v4:sys:compile.f18 (23099 bytes, hash=0xb46bf77ceee7245a) + [p] v4:sys:end.f18 (1452 bytes, hash=0x98fd33b1c431cfe7) + [p] v4:starshipos.4th (706 bytes, hash=0x1734a8f4fe7483a5) + [p] v4:hera.4th (1376 bytes, hash=0x78730b1d6effe892) + [p] v4:rom:sym.f18 (5610 bytes, hash=0xbbad5748f5bbf863) + [p] v4:rom:main.f18 (2284 bytes, hash=0x6994f1f1d567e163) + [p] v4:rom:math.f18 (5108 bytes, hash=0x9be63ad87934622f) + [p] v4:rom:dir.f18 (5112 bytes, hash=0x51b069f0623ded16) + [p] v4:rom:num.f18 (2634 bytes, hash=0x08b76f1b058cac17) + [p] v4:rom:pack.f18 (4583 bytes, hash=0x65a944d8eb7de7f2) + [p] v4:rom:word.f18 (12966 bytes, hash=0x9210d6c2ac424d11) + [p] v4:rom:in.f18 (4230 bytes, hash=0x65798bed38a09f0f) + [p] v4:rom:mesh.f18 (449 bytes, hash=0x83723d76b9620c2c) + [p] v4:centre.4th (4140 bytes, hash=0x53b1e3df644e8e25) + [p] README.md (2305 bytes, hash=0x09a684ebdfbeb01c) + [p] block-acl.4th (980 bytes, hash=0xf6cc2a59e3a6734e) + [p] sdk.4th (2295 bytes, hash=0x008fdbbb62c94a3a) + [p] pki:starshipos-intermediate.der (408 bytes, hash=0xb40aab540c19f877) + [p] init-l8-omni.4th (1986 bytes, hash=0x5979e314d6452045) + [p] acl-std79.4th (5040 bytes, hash=0x773bf9209df191d1) + [p] doe-campaign.4th (2369 bytes, hash=0x26fb485e5c9dc6ff) + [p] init-l8-volatile.4th (718 bytes, hash=0x98caabbbd92abac4) + [p] doe.4th (3244 bytes, hash=0xf154616d248e861f) + [p] fabric.4th (10359 bytes, hash=0x9d9489cbeca4099b) + [p] workload-4.4th (469 bytes, hash=0x099619264e650b1c) + [p] init-l8-temporal.4th (363 bytes, hash=0x51abd4c138246651) + [p] workload-5.4th (480 bytes, hash=0x526964c7c9506a11) + [p] fonts:README.md (1846 bytes, hash=0xf628c2b7a49f4d46) + [p] fonts:JetBrainsMono-Regular.ttf (270224 bytes, hash=0xf4b7077dab274e6b) + [p] init-l8-transition.4th (529 bytes, hash=0xbcc1a81976f0a4c9) + [p] workload-2.4th (1321 bytes, hash=0xf113b3d0bcccae47) + [p] workload-1.4th (1041 bytes, hash=0x63e251adb0a03613) + [p] workload-5-lite.4th (468 bytes, hash=0xea0303f38824f254) + [p] workload-0.4th (290 bytes, hash=0x93f86f60aeba8feb) + [p] artemis:init.4th (16782 bytes, hash=0x7ba120e2a6aab239) + [p] MANIFEST.md (35813 bytes, hash=0x9d3a6fdb7415d224) + [p] workload-7.4th (206 bytes, hash=0x02862291387eb7ac) + [p] BLOCK_MAP.md (22886 bytes, hash=0x86df913cdae857c6) + [p] turtle.4th (3254 bytes, hash=0x4d470418ca543365) + [p] workload-8.4th (172 bytes, hash=0x56b7f2f0efa000df) + [p] workload-6.4th (1986 bytes, hash=0x06fc0ce1e369ef5a) +mkcapsule: 76 capsule(s) collected +mkcapsule: wrote /home/user/LithosAnanke/v4/build/capsule_generated.c + [mesh boot, V4_CELL_BITS=64] +v4 mesh boot: V4_CELL_BITS=64 + PARITY:V4_POST tests=990 pass=990 fail=0 + 114 checks, 0 failures diff --git a/logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-before.log b/logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-before.log new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c234dc70 --- /dev/null +++ b/logs/20261119-pin-births/test_mesh_boot-before.log @@ -0,0 +1,96 @@ +mkcapsule: scanning /home/user/LithosAnanke/capsules + [p] zuse.4th (1684 bytes, hash=0x490ded9be257a90b) + [p] font.4th (17688 bytes, hash=0x3f305911500c78f6) + [p] MANIFEST_AUTO.md (11687 bytes, hash=0xe022545a0755960f) + [p] multiuser-doe.4th (3942 bytes, hash=0x22140588ee7c39e6) + [p] hestia:init.4th (891 bytes, hash=0x64e111990fbc45ff) + [p] contrib:README.md (1855 bytes, hash=0x4212e52b927793e7) + [p] ACL.4th (4318 bytes, hash=0xf8890c05c0d8f921) + [p] workload-3.4th (2189 bytes, hash=0x62b7a71576ad1041) + [p] init-l8-diverse.4th (430 bytes, hash=0xaa293201a6c91838) + [p] user-font-demo.4th (1674 bytes, hash=0xce1fd7d1b581a56d) + [p] workload-9.4th (1321 bytes, hash=0x3f2bec73142aa424) + [p] lib.4th (619 bytes, hash=0x4b216635c359ef73) + [p] workload-calib1.4th (304 bytes, hash=0x3b9f2d17b554fabc) + [m] init.4th (669 bytes, hash=0xd09db9461b336431) + [p] workload-1-lite.4th (540 bytes, hash=0x44a7a7e3176dcc8d) + [p] init-l8-stable.4th (278 bytes, hash=0xdc3830f189063a9a) + [p] v4:physics.4th (2953 bytes, hash=0x5b0195fc30828bde) + [p] v4:forth79.4th (1216 bytes, hash=0x4609d6ef54166ef8) + [p] v4:ACL.4th (2103 bytes, hash=0xdba5690fb0ee12a4) + [p] v4:init.4th (425 bytes, hash=0x24af6802c576c1c1) + [p] v4:sys:log.f18 (4535 bytes, hash=0x544cd004233dff62) + [p] v4:sys:qmath.f18 (8607 bytes, hash=0xa93783c2c8f9b7db) + [p] v4:sys:map-32.f18 (3162 bytes, hash=0x5bdf8cbbebdd3c8f) + [p] v4:sys:blocks.f18 (6112 bytes, hash=0x09d361dbe6174236) + [p] v4:sys:input.f18 (10692 bytes, hash=0x0f13c3f9d5fd07fc) + [p] v4:sys:dict.f18 (13816 bytes, hash=0xe3453808afd5a0af) + [p] v4:sys:forth.f18 (12617 bytes, hash=0xc4c0ad315c95eda4) + [p] v4:sys:quit.f18 (32141 bytes, hash=0x7fa7a7668b6bf1ed) + [p] v4:sys:map-64.f18 (3201 bytes, hash=0x06cb44832df2b8fd) + [p] v4:sys:codegen.f18 (4999 bytes, hash=0x36d2ae84d2911b90) + [p] v4:sys:acl.f18 (4100 bytes, hash=0x76e7e746befa2733) + [p] v4:sys:core.f18 (24370 bytes, hash=0x0f415502fccc3fba) + [p] v4:sys:system.f18 (10189 bytes, hash=0xfe257eb084c43a5d) + [p] v4:sys:numout.f18 (6641 bytes, hash=0xca0fb0f9c1589e20) + [p] v4:sys:words.f18 (9642 bytes, hash=0x2f4e5f7f3e7f736f) + [p] v4:sys:compile.f18 (23099 bytes, hash=0xb46bf77ceee7245a) + [p] v4:sys:end.f18 (1452 bytes, hash=0x98fd33b1c431cfe7) + [p] v4:starshipos.4th (706 bytes, hash=0x1734a8f4fe7483a5) + [p] v4:hera.4th (1376 bytes, hash=0x78730b1d6effe892) + [p] v4:rom:sym.f18 (5610 bytes, hash=0xbbad5748f5bbf863) + [p] v4:rom:main.f18 (2284 bytes, hash=0x6994f1f1d567e163) + [p] v4:rom:math.f18 (5108 bytes, hash=0x9be63ad87934622f) + [p] v4:rom:dir.f18 (5112 bytes, hash=0x51b069f0623ded16) + [p] v4:rom:num.f18 (2634 bytes, hash=0x08b76f1b058cac17) + [p] v4:rom:pack.f18 (4583 bytes, hash=0x65a944d8eb7de7f2) + [p] v4:rom:word.f18 (12966 bytes, hash=0x9210d6c2ac424d11) + [p] v4:rom:in.f18 (4230 bytes, hash=0x65798bed38a09f0f) + [p] v4:rom:mesh.f18 (449 bytes, hash=0x83723d76b9620c2c) + [p] v4:centre.4th (4140 bytes, hash=0x53b1e3df644e8e25) + [p] README.md (2305 bytes, hash=0x09a684ebdfbeb01c) + [p] block-acl.4th (980 bytes, hash=0xf6cc2a59e3a6734e) + [p] sdk.4th (2295 bytes, hash=0x008fdbbb62c94a3a) + [p] pki:starshipos-intermediate.der (408 bytes, hash=0xb40aab540c19f877) + [p] init-l8-omni.4th (1986 bytes, hash=0x5979e314d6452045) + [p] acl-std79.4th (5040 bytes, hash=0x773bf9209df191d1) + [p] doe-campaign.4th (2369 bytes, hash=0x26fb485e5c9dc6ff) + [p] init-l8-volatile.4th (718 bytes, hash=0x98caabbbd92abac4) + [p] doe.4th (3244 bytes, hash=0xf154616d248e861f) + [p] fabric.4th (10359 bytes, hash=0x9d9489cbeca4099b) + [p] workload-4.4th (469 bytes, hash=0x099619264e650b1c) + [p] init-l8-temporal.4th (363 bytes, hash=0x51abd4c138246651) + [p] workload-5.4th (480 bytes, hash=0x526964c7c9506a11) + [p] fonts:README.md (1846 bytes, hash=0xf628c2b7a49f4d46) + [p] fonts:JetBrainsMono-Regular.ttf (270224 bytes, hash=0xf4b7077dab274e6b) + [p] init-l8-transition.4th (529 bytes, hash=0xbcc1a81976f0a4c9) + [p] workload-2.4th (1321 bytes, hash=0xf113b3d0bcccae47) + [p] workload-1.4th (1041 bytes, hash=0x63e251adb0a03613) + [p] workload-5-lite.4th (468 bytes, hash=0xea0303f38824f254) + [p] workload-0.4th (290 bytes, hash=0x93f86f60aeba8feb) + [p] artemis:init.4th (16782 bytes, hash=0x7ba120e2a6aab239) + [p] MANIFEST.md (35813 bytes, hash=0x9d3a6fdb7415d224) + [p] workload-7.4th (206 bytes, hash=0x02862291387eb7ac) + [p] BLOCK_MAP.md (22886 bytes, hash=0x86df913cdae857c6) + [p] turtle.4th (3254 bytes, hash=0x4d470418ca543365) + [p] workload-8.4th (172 bytes, hash=0x56b7f2f0efa000df) + [p] workload-6.4th (1986 bytes, hash=0x06fc0ce1e369ef5a) +mkcapsule: 76 capsule(s) collected +mkcapsule: wrote /home/user/LithosAnanke/v4/build/capsule_generated.c + [mesh boot, V4_CELL_BITS=64] +v4 mesh boot: V4_CELL_BITS=64 + PARITY:V4_POST tests=990 pass=990 fail=0 + not pinned: BIRTH: "0 " + not pinned: BIRTH-AS: "0 " + not pinned: UNIT: "0 " + not pinned: KILL: "0 " + not pinned: UNIT-KILL: "0 " + not pinned: PAUSE: "0 " + not pinned: RESUME: "0 " + not pinned: NODE-BORN: "0 " + not pinned: NODE-KILL: "0 " + not pinned: NODE-SLEEP: "0 " + not pinned: NODE-WAKE: "0 " +FAIL /home/user/LithosAnanke/v4/tests/test_mesh_boot.c:165: init.4th pinned the 11 words that create or end nodes + 114 checks, 1 failures +make: *** [Makefile:380: mesh-boot] Error 1 diff --git a/v4/tests/test_mesh_boot.c b/v4/tests/test_mesh_boot.c index d301c570..4b39b8cf 100644 --- a/v4/tests/test_mesh_boot.c +++ b/v4/tests/test_mesh_boot.c @@ -152,6 +152,18 @@ int main(void) CHECK(how == V4_TEXT_COMPLETED && strcmp(r, "ok") == 0, "init.4th set the search order: DOE is found without naming STARSHIPOS: \"%s\" (%d)", r, how); r = line(V4_MESH_HERA, "' ACL-BOOT ACL-PINNED? . ' ACL-RECHECK ACL-PINNED? .", &how); CHECK(how == V4_TEXT_COMPLETED && strcmp(r, "-1 -1 ") == 0, "init.4th turned security on: the ACL policy is loaded, its words pinned: \"%s\" (%d)", r, how); + { /* the words that create or end nodes, pinned by init.4th (ruled 2026-11-19: "Also pin the kernel words") */ + static const char *const pinned[] = { "BIRTH", "BIRTH-AS", "UNIT", "KILL", "UNIT-KILL", "PAUSE", "RESUME", + "NODE-BORN", "NODE-KILL", "NODE-SLEEP", "NODE-WAKE" }; + unsigned k, all = 1; + char q[64]; + for (k = 0; k < sizeof pinned / sizeof pinned[0]; k++) { + snprintf(q, sizeof q, "' %s ACL-PINNED? .", pinned[k]); + r = line(V4_MESH_HERA, q, &how); + if (how != V4_TEXT_COMPLETED || strcmp(r, "-1 ") != 0) { all = 0; printf(" not pinned: %s: \"%s\"\n", pinned[k], r); } + } + CHECK(all, "init.4th pinned the %u words that create or end nodes", (unsigned)(sizeof pinned / sizeof pinned[0])); + } r = line(V4_MESH_HERA, "1900 BLOCK 16 TYPE", &how); CHECK(how == V4_TEXT_COMPLETED && strncmp(r, "( forth79.4th --", 16) == 0, "forth79.4th's lowest block is in RAM block 1900: \"%.20s\" (%d)", r, how); /* starshipos.4th, a system capsule loaded before POST (MACHINE.md 3, step 3; ruled 2026-11-18) */