docs(v4): whole-POST parity ruled -- v3's table, not v3's bugs (#189)

Captain Bob, 2026-11-14: where v3 does not do what its own table says, v4 is held to the table; where a
case's output names v3's internals, to the same form with v4's values; both listed. POST-PARITY.md, the
Phase 7 plan's Task 8. Not pushed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017RzZgrf7V7Zk2iczBXDRbm
This commit is contained in:
Claude
2026-11-14 02:19:49 +00:00
parent fa5a5c7096
commit 5cac792627
2 changed files with 13 additions and 1 deletions
+5
View File
@@ -93,3 +93,8 @@ What they are:
4. **v3 not doing what its own table says** (29 cases; e.g. `2!.basic`): the expectation recorded is v3's 4. **v3 not doing what its own table says** (29 cases; e.g. `2!.basic`): the expectation recorded is v3's
error, and a v4 that does what the table says fails it. error, and a v4 that does what the table says fails it.
5. The rest -- formatting, the stress and integration groups -- case by case. 5. The rest -- formatting, the stress and integration groups -- case by case.
**Ruled (Captain Bob, 2026-11-14): "v3's table, not v3's bugs".** Where v3 does not do what its own table
says (kind 4: 29 cases), v4 is held to the table -- what v3 meant -- and each such case is listed. Where a
case's output names v3's internals (kind 3), v4 is held to the same form with its own words: the case's
shape, v4's values; listed too. Everything else: v3's recorded behaviour, exactly.
@@ -198,7 +198,14 @@ Phase 4).
### Task 5: the StarForth words (Phase 3's: `init.4th`, `starforth.4th`), and their POST ### Task 5: the StarForth words (Phase 3's: `init.4th`, `starforth.4th`), and their POST
### Task 6: the ACL (Phase 4's: `ACL.4th`, the word card, the countdown), and its POST ### Task 6: the ACL (Phase 4's: `ACL.4th`, the word card, the countdown), and its POST
### Task 7: the block cases (Phase 5's part) ### Task 7: the block cases (Phase 5's part)
### Task 8: `mkpost.py` beyond the Required set: v3's whole POST as v4's; the floor raised ### Task 8: `mkpost.py` beyond the Required set
- [x] `mkpost.py --all --out FILE`: the whole POST as a table, measured on Hera in the fabric -- 1020 cases,
849 pass, 171 fail (`POST-PARITY.md` section 5).
- [x] Ruled (2026-11-14): "v3's table, not v3's bugs" -- v3's self-disagreements held to its table, cases
naming v3's internals held to their form with v4's values; both listed.
- [ ] The 171, by kind: address units (rules); what v4 lacks (`SP@` `SP!` `CASE` `SKIP` `SCAN` `SEARCH`
`COMPARE` `ORDER` `THRU` `FLUSH` ...); v3's self-disagreements and v3-internal output (by the ruling);
the rest case by case. Then the whole table becomes v4's POST and its floor.: v3's whole POST as v4's; the floor raised
### Task 9: acceptance -- the full protocol; ENGINE.md, V3-PARITY.md, FABRIC-3 ### Task 9: acceptance -- the full protocol; ENGINE.md, V3-PARITY.md, FABRIC-3
Each task gets its steps when the one before it is accepted, test first, as Phase 2's did. Each task gets its steps when the one before it is accepted, test first, as Phase 2's did.