Advisor review of the Phase 5 close-out commit caught two real issues:
- Task 5.1's write-up claimed the Isabelle pass "confirms no regression" --
overstated. Nothing in proof/'s scope changed, so the pass isn't
regression evidence, it's a build-completeness formality; the boundary
argument alone already supports the real conclusion. Sharpened.
- sbom.spdx was regenerated before the 5.4 version bump, so it briefly
understated the engine version. Root cause: the hosted Makefile carries
its own separate hardcoded VERSION (Makefile:17, still 3.1.0), distinct
from Makefile.starkernel's copy that 5.4 bumped -- duplication CLAUDE.md's
own "two independently tracked version strings" note doesn't document.
Bumped to 3.2.0 to match, regenerated (PackageVersion now correct), and
rebuilt the hosted starforth binary so lfs/amd64/starforth reflects it.
Also recorded why 5.1-5.4 landed as one commit (deviation from this
document's per-task-commit discipline) and sharpened the riscv64 log
entry so the FAILED run and the accepted retry aren't ambiguous to a
future reader grepping logs/.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
5.1: Isabelle/HOL pass (52 theories, clean) -- restated the boundary rather
than just citing the green build: proof/ scope was already entirely
outside this reshuffle's footprint (src/starkernel/, capsules/*.4th),
so the boundary is unchanged, not moved.
5.2: Documentation sweep. CLAUDE.md's stale WIP banner and Tripod fleet
description updated now that Phases 0-4 have actually landed (Hera/
Artemis/Hestia, no Hermes). MANIFEST.md rides the strip -- hermes/init.4th's
block table replaced with a deletion note, init.4th/doe-campaign.4th/
hestia/init.4th entries corrected to match the post-strip live files.
Confirmed the TRIPOD.md/0.1 contradiction was already resolved (2026-08-13).
Settled the superseded-docs call explicitly: archive as-is, do not rewrite.
Fixed experiments/bare_metal/README.md's block-size framing (still said
1024-byte budget; real rule is 64 chars x 16 lines). K-qualification
checked clean against the two living documents; full retroactive sweep
of the closed archival FABRIC corpus explicitly declined as disproportionate.
5.3: make sbom. Installed syft (user-local, approved). Found and fixed a
real Makefile bug while at it -- the sbom target hardcoded
--source-name StarForth, so DocumentName was wrong even after regenerating.
5.4: LITHOS_VERSION 2.0.0 -> 2.1.0, engine VERSION 3.1.0 -> 3.2.0 (minor,
per the dictionary-visible-only rule). Replaced the stale version-comment
block in Makefile.starkernel (had the odd/even LTS rule backwards) and
docs/lithosananke/ROADMAP.md's retired versioning-policy section with the
ratified ladder. Verified on all three architectures; riscv64's first pass
hit a transient virtio_blk timeout during boot-time Zuse genesis mint,
reported and confirmed non-reproducing on an immediate clean retry.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
